This guide is general information about clauses commonly found in large-builder purchase agreements, including D.R. Horton's, not legal advice. Contract forms vary by state and community and change over time — what matters is the document in front of you. If significant money is at stake, consult a licensed attorney promptly.
A production builder's contract is not a negotiation between equals. It's a form the builder's lawyers drafted, refined over thousands of transactions, and — per D.R. Horton's own published sales policies — its sales agents do not have the authority to modify. That single fact shapes everything else in this guide: whatever protection you get has to already be in the document, because the person across the table can't add it.
Red flag 1: The arbitration clause
This is the best-documented clause in the D.R. Horton agreement, and the one buyers most often miss. Horton's contracts have long required disputes to go to binding arbitration instead of court. In a Texas appellate case over a construction defect, the court enforced the clause as written: it covered essentially any claim or dispute between buyer and seller related to the transaction, and it survived closing — meaning it still governed defect claims discovered after the buyer owned the home.
Consumer advocates have flagged Horton among the large builders that require forced arbitration. What to check in your copy:
- Scope. Does it cover "any claim, controversy or dispute" — including construction defects found years later — or is it limited to contract disputes?
- Survival. Does the clause survive closing and delivery of the deed? If it does, your post-closing defect remedies run through arbitration too.
- Costs. Who pays the arbitrator and filing fees? Some forms split them; that can still mean thousands out of pocket before your claim is heard.
- Class actions and juries. Binding arbitration typically means no jury trial and no joining other buyers with the same defect. Know that you're trading those away at signing, not at dispute time.
Red flag 2: Earnest money — due immediately, refundable on whose terms?
Horton's published sales policies require an earnest money deposit on the date you write the contract. The amount is only half the question. The other half is the refund language:
- When does the deposit become non-refundable? After a deadline, after certain contingencies expire, or from day one?
- What happens if the builder defaults or misses the closing window? In many builder forms, the buyer's remedy on a builder default is limited to getting the deposit back — nothing more. Check whether yours caps the builder's liability that way.
- What happens if you default? Builder forms commonly let the seller keep the deposit as liquidated damages. That's the asymmetry to look for: your default costs you the deposit; the builder's default costs the builder nothing beyond returning it.
- Additional deposits. Design-center upgrades and options often require further deposits, frequently non-refundable once ordered. Total your real exposure — it's usually more than the headline earnest money.
Red flag 3: Verbal promises aren't in the deal
Horton's own policies state that its sales agents lack authority to modify the purchase agreement, and that if the policies and the agreement conflict, the agreement controls. Most large-builder forms also contain an integration clause saying the written contract is the entire deal. Together, those mean:
- "We'll take care of that at the walkthrough," "that lot premium includes the fence," and "closing will definitely be before your lease ends" are worth exactly nothing unless they're written into the contract or an addendum.
- If something the salesperson promised matters to you, it has to be in the document before you sign — afterward, the agent who promised it couldn't have bound the builder anyway.
Red flag 4: Closing date and delay language
Production schedules slip, and builder contracts are written with that in mind. Check yours for:
- A firm closing date vs. an estimated window. Many forms give the builder a broad window — sometimes many months — plus extensions for weather, materials, and permit delays.
- Your costs when the date moves. Rate-lock expirations, temporary housing, and storage fall on the buyer in most forms. Is there any builder obligation — a per-day credit, a lock-extension contribution — or is delay risk entirely yours?
- Your exit right. If the builder blows past the outside date, can you cancel and recover your deposits — all of them, including design deposits — or only the earnest money?
Red flag 5: Price, options, and substitution language
- Price adjustments. Look for escalation or cost-adjustment language that lets the builder raise the price after signing, and whether it's capped. (Our separate guide on what to do when a builder raises the price after signing walks through this in full.)
- "Or equal" substitutions. Builder forms routinely allow substituting materials, fixtures, and appliances with equivalents the builder selects. If a specific brand or model is part of why you're buying, it needs to be specified — and even then, check the substitution clause.
- Plan and community changes. Forms often reserve the builder's right to change floor plans, community amenities, and future phases. The model home's phase is what you see; the contract may not guarantee the rest.
Red flag 6: Contingencies the builder doesn't have to accept
Horton's published policies reserve the right to decline offers contingent on the sale of the buyer's existing home. If your purchase depends on selling your current house — or on appraisal, or financing on specific terms — confirm the contingency is actually in your contract, with dates, rather than assuming a standard protection exists. In a builder form, a protection that isn't written in isn't there.
Before you sign: the five-minute version
- Find the arbitration clause. Note its scope, whether it survives closing, and who pays.
- Total every deposit — earnest money plus design/options deposits — and find the exact conditions under which each is refundable.
- Compare the default clauses side by side: what you lose if you default vs. what the builder loses if it does.
- Write down every verbal promise made at the sales office. If it's not in the contract or an addendum, treat it as not promised.
- Find the closing window and the delay language, and price your worst case: a lock extension plus two months of temporary housing.
None of this means "don't buy." D.R. Horton sells more homes than anyone in the country, and most transactions close fine. It means the contract is the builder's document, written for the builder's worst day — and the time to learn what it says about your worst day is before your deposit is in.
Read the fine print before it reads you.
Contract X-Ray scans builder contracts — including D.R. Horton purchase agreements — for arbitration clauses, deposit traps, escalation language, and one-sided default terms, and gives you a plain-English report in minutes, before you sign.
Get your contract scanned — $149Automated review, not legal advice. Always have a licensed attorney review your contract before signing.